Maine Lobster Rolls

I know I’ve been neglecting these pages, but I had a good reason: I’ve spent last weekend in Maine, reveling in sand dunes, salty air, and buckets of fresh seafood.
Somehow I’ve spent a decade on the East Coast without ever venturing that far north. My friends were amused at my newfound delight at the North Atlantic seashore, so different from the flashy Southern California beaches I grew up with.
I love everything about it – the wooden steps down to the beach, the waves of sea grass, the brambly magenta flowers, charmingly called beach plums, that crawl along the shoreline.

Most of all, I love lobster rolls. My appreciation for them, sparked by my first taste earlier this summer in Cape Cod, has blossomed into a full-out obsession.
Whole lobster itself I could take or leave. But stuff it in a warm, buttery roll with some lemon and herbs, with just a sprig of lettuce and a hint of mayo, and I’m in heaven.

Every lobster roll I’ve eaten so far, all consumed within earshot of the ocean, has been delicious in a different way. As with BBQ or New York pizza, there seem to be fiercely devoted camps about the details – Butter or mayo? Seasoned or simple?
I’m on a mission to try them all. Everywhere I go now I see lobster rolls – at the flea market, at my local fishmonger, at the nondescript cafe across the street. By the end of summer I plan to have a perfect recipe, to bring the taste of Maine beach back to Brooklyn.




Love those beautiful photos! I’ve never had a lobster roll and I always struggle a bit with lobster. Not to fond of the whole cleaning part, but this sounds like a perfect way for me to get into lobster (well, as long as someone else puts it in the roll that is..:))
Oh my oh my!! How delicious. I have always wanted to go to Maine and your photos are so beautiful that I may insist that we visit next time I am back home in the States to visit. I absolutely love the last photo, such a lovely detail!
Well, from s born and raised Mainer (AKA Maine-iac), I say mayo. I tell everyone that melted butter is for tourists only.
Rolls are my favorite way of eating lobster, too. I like plenty of mayo with mine. Delicious!
Can you believe that lobster was considered a poor man’s food at one time? They used to scoop them up on the shore (years ago) and people would do all they could to hide the shells for fear of being labeled as “poor.”
Now you can appreciate why we spend as much time in Maine as we can. In the future you need to explore the coast further (farther?) north, where we’re headed this week. Nice pictures. We vote mayo.
Brian – I never knew that about poor man’s food, thanks!
You’re welcome, Liz. Isn’t that anmazing? I read that in Down East nagazine several years ago. I don’t know when it was now…just many, many years ago…maybe around 1900 or so. Lobster was so abundant back then people could just pick up all they could eat right at the shore. So poor people often did. That’s hot it got its bad reputation. How things have changed!
Sorry for the typos…something odd going on with my keypad.
Fantastic! Dave and I had several lobster rolls while touring various clam shacks in Rhode Island. I also vote mayo. What a perfect summer treat! (Best eaten sitting on the sand, looking out at the ocean (in Maine: “the shore”).